# Independent review packet

Record: task/spec and selected artifact; exact comparison; inspected files/paths; findings; acceptance matrix; actual checks; limitations; documentation proposal; next owner action.

Finding example:

```markdown
### High impact: stale revision can overwrite an external edit
Trigger: change the Markdown file after loading the edit form, then save.
Observed: the incoming body replaces the external version.
Expected: retain both versions and expose a recoverable conflict.
Evidence: exact source location, reproduction, revisions and output.
Remedy: compare current file identity/revision at the mutation boundary.
```

Use findings grounded in a real trigger, not imagined hazards. The acceptance matrix distinguishes Passed, Failed, Unknown and an explicit owner Waiver. If evidence comes from another agent, identify it as a report until independently checked. A review without findings still states what was and was not examined.

Record the packet via DOC/LOG, link the task and run/session when known, and retain Review. The current agent MCP does not mark Done or resume provider sessions.